Reader Jim K. writes:
Found and fell in love with your site from another site (google redirect) and have to admit, love all the photos and simplicity that surrounds many of your pictures. I need a suggestion though, I don't take pictures but my wife does and wants a new camera, though she's not a fan of bulk, could you possibly recommend an all-around camera that is good for basic pictures? Price is no object, though nothing I'll regret buying her and having her break (like a Leica).
MATT: Thanks for your kind comments. I appreciate them very much.
It's tough to recommend a specific camera because there are so many variables (available camera models, lens models, form factor, weight, price, photographer shooting style and skill-level, etc). Also, my experiences over the past several years have been limited to just a handful of cameras. The Nikon D90, D7000, and D3s DSLRS; the Canon PowerShot G11; and the Fuji X100 rangefinder-style camera. I sold the D90 and the D7000 last year, so today I primarily use the D3s and the X100 for personal shooting (my wife and kids use the G11, occasionally). The bottom line is that I've only used a small fraction of the cameras that are available on the market today, so please read my response with that in mind.
Here are some brief thoughts on each of the five recent cameras I've owned, in the order that I bought them:
Nikon D90
A quality mid-sized DSLR that I loved. Although the D90 went into production years ago, it's still widely available and there were brand new ones on the shelves of my local camera shop as recently as a few weeks ago. A great camera, but the newer D7000 might be a better choice for its improved low-light performance.
Canon PowerShot G11
Small, compact, well-built, but somewhat dated. I've had it for several years, and although many great reviews have been written about it, I've been disappointed with the pictures I've been able to get out of it. As a result, I haven't used it a lot and I can't recommend it. The current model is the G12, by the way, but the differences are minimal.
Nikon D3s
An incredible camera. By far my favorite, past or present! Amazing low-light performance, built like a tank. Love it, love it, love it! But, I can't recommend it for your wife because it's huge, it weighs a ton, and it's price is approaching Leica territory.
Nikon D7000
This is probably a great little camera, but I sold mine just a few months after I bought it. I intended it to be a small alternative to the D3s - a camera that I'd carry whenever I didn't feel like lugging around the big D3s. But, I couldn't get used to the way the shutter operated. It sounded cheap compared to the D3s, and worse, I couldn't hold the camera still when the shutter was triggered. The way the camera "torqued" each time I released the shutter drove me crazy, so I got rid of it. Still, it might be worth a look. I may have been hopelessly spoiled by the D3s, so I wouldn't rule the D7000 out for your wife.
Fuji X100
A surprisingly nice camera. This might fit the bill for your wife. It's relatively compact (think purse, not pocket) and it takes great photos. I think it can match the image quality I got out of my beloved D90, even though it's smaller and weighs a lot less. There's no zoom feature, though, and the lens is not interchangeable, so if your wife wants a close-up shot, she'll have to BE close-up. For me, the X100 is a nice, carry-all-the-time camera that bridges the gap between my iPhone 4 (which takes terrible pictures, but is oh-so-convenient) and the heavy-weight champ of my collection, the D3s.