A Tale of Two Bear Bells
Jan 1, 2012 at 08:22PM |
Matt Hyatt A heart-pounding run through the woods in the dark is exhilarating, a cheap thrill that’s even better when the family dog is along for the experience.

Bear Bells and Raccoon Tracks along the Chattahoochee River
During the winter, when the sun sets around 5:30 in the afternoon, I like to go hiking or trail running at dusk, which usually means running around the woods in the dark. With nobody around to complain, I often bring Wilson the Bassador along and let him run off leash. He loves it and I enjoy the company. Occasionally, though, he’ll go tearing off into the darkness after a raccoon or a deer, and once in a while, he takes his sweet time finding his way back. In fact, twice now he’s been missing long enough that I started to worry that he was lost for good.
Finding a black dog in the woods at night isn’t as easy as it sounds, so it occurred to me a while back that Wilson would be easier to find if I attached a bear bell to his collar. So, I picked up a Coghlan’s Bear Bell from REI for $3.95 and was excited to try it out, but it fell off on our very first run, never to be found again (UPDATE: I found the bell five nights later, while running through the same park with an awesome 750 lumen Lupine Piko headlamp). The hook and loop fastener that’s meant to secure the bell simply isn't big or strong enough to do the job. No matter, though. The magnet in the permanently-attached netted pouch kept sticking to the side of the bell, dampening the ring while Wilson ran and rendering the bell useless. On the plus side, the magnetized pouch effectively silenced the bell during transport to and from the trailhead, a feature that is missing from the bear bell I received for Christmas this year.
The Silverfoot Hiker Carabiner Bear Bell was a gift from Santa, presumably intended to be used as the manufacturer envisioned (to warn bears of approaching hikers). Conveniently, it was a perfect replacement for the “dog” bear bell that was lost. The Silverfoot bell sported a superior design, too, utilizing a small carabiner for secure attachment to Wilson’s collar and lacking a clanger-muting magnet. At $10, it’s 150% more expensive than the Coghlan bell, but it seems much less likely to get lost. Unless I fling it away, that is. It drives me crazy when it jingles Rudolph-style while I carry it around in my backpack to and from the trailhead.
The bottom line is that the Silverfoot Hiker Carabiner Bear Bell is the better buy for dogs. It has a more secure attachment mechanism than the Coghlan bell, and it lacks a magnet that may unintentionally stop the bell from ringing. To be honest, though, I suspect a jingle bell and a zip tie from your local craft store would accomplish a similar result for about $1.













